John Candy in ‘Splash’ and Jack Nicholson.Photo:Everett, Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty

SPLASH, John Candy, 1984, Jack Nicholson

Everett, Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty

John Candyfilmed a memorable scene in 1984’sSplashon very little sleep, a producer on the film has revealed.

Longtime Hollywood producer Brian Grazer shared some memories of the late Candy, who died at age 43 in 1994, during an appearance onThe Rich Eisen Showto promote his new sports docuseries about the New England Patriots. During the episode, host Eisen, 54, asked specifically whether stories that Candy “was hungover forthe racquetball scene” were true.

“Yes. For real, he stayed out withJack Nicholsonuntil like four or five in the morning and then he went right to work,” Grazer, 72, said. “John Candy had a lot of endurance, I mean really, a lot of endurance.”

“The night with Nicholson, I think he overdid it, so he literally ran into the ball that hit him in the head,” the producer recalled. “That was real — we anticipated, we knew we’d have to shoot it in two shots, because the minute he hit that ball, it hit him right in the head, he couldn’t get out of the way of it.”

Tom Hanks and John Candy in 1984’s Splash.Touchstone/Kobal/Shutterstock

Tom Hanks, John Candy Splash - 1984

Touchstone/Kobal/Shutterstock

Candy costarred alongsideTom HanksinSplash, a romantic comedy with fantasy elements that follows a man named Allen (Hanks) who falls in love with a woman who is secretly a mermaid (Daryl Hannah). Candy played Hanks on-screen brother, Freddie.

Released on March 9,Splashwent on to become the 11th highest-grossing movie of 1984 at thedomestic box officeand received anAcademy Awardnomination for Best Original Screenplay at the57th Oscars.

During Grazer’s appearance on Eisen’s show, he also recalled witnessing Candy drink “17 small rum and cokes” while meeting with the actor to determine if he would take part in the movie. “But he drank ‘em like one after the next and he lit up and was fun and never got sloppy, he just kept going,” the producer said.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Splash, Eugene Levy, Daryl Hannah, Tom Hanks, John Candy

The story of the late Candy arriving late and hungover toSplash’s set in order to shoot that scene has bounced around for some time. Grazer, Hanks, Hannah, costarEugene Levyand the movie’s directorRon Howardshared the same story during an appearance on Josh Gad’sReunited ApartYouTube seriesin 2020, including that Candy managed to make the racquet ball hit him in the head on a rebound on his very first attempt.

“John, totally professional guy, but he’s late one day… and John finally pulls up and rolls out of the car and he says, ‘Ron, I’m so sorry.’ I said, ‘It’s OK. You’re late, but we’ll get going.’ He said, ‘No, no, no. Look, I’m drunk,’ " Howard recalled of interacting with Candy that day.

Splash, Eugene Levy, Tom Hanks, John Candy

“Here’s what happened — I’m telling you the truth — I’m at the bar and Jack Nicholson is at the bar,' " he recalled Candy saying. “‘Jack Nicholson knew my name, Ron! And he starts buying me drinks. [Candy] said, ‘But I’ve got to go shoot.’ And [Nicholson] said, ‘You’re going to be all right, kid. Don’t worry about it.’ "

Howard also said that Candy told him he “never went to bed” before arriving to shoot the scene.

source: people.com