When you purchase through links on our site , we may earn an affiliate committee . Here ’s how it works .
" The Iceman " Wim Hofclaims a compounding of breathing exercises and cold picture can bring people many benefits , include increase self-control ; rich loss ; a " fortified " immune response ; " balanced " hormones ; and reduced inflammation .
The jury is still out onwhether the Wim Hof Method ( WHM ) has any of these benefits , but are the education also dangerous ?
Wim Hof talks to one of his trainees in Poland in 2016.
Experts told Live Science that some of Hof ’s practices , as shown in some videos online , pose a risk of drowning , as well as potentially dangerous fondness - rhythm irregularities . However , a interpreter for the WHM say these videos are not reflective of the official method acting , but simply example of Hof doing " uttermost feats , " and that they provide safety videos and instructions on their website explain how to safely practice the WHM .
Whatever the official guidance on the WHM website states , some Wim Hof - denounce social media video give a very unlike , and grievous , impression of how to rehearse the method acting , experts say . What ’s more , there is evidence that people have died doing WHM breathing exercises while in water .
Related : How to swim in the sea
A Wim Hof method trainee in Poland in 2016.
What is the “Wim Hof Method”?
The canonical WHM ventilation exercisedescribed on the fellowship ’s websiteinvolves taking cryptic , successive hint , a form of deliberate hyperventilation . After hyperventilate , you hold your breath " until you feel the urge to breathe again . "
individually , the WHM also demand " cold therapy , " or exposure to cold . The WHM internet site says cold therapy can involve insensate showers and ice tub . However , insocial culture medium video , Hof and other practitioners often submerge themselves in bodies of water outside .
There are also pay WHM on-line courses , which hold out Science did n’t access while report this story . ( Nor did Live Science watch theWHM - focused installment of " The Goop research lab " , sport Gwyneth Paltrow . )
Jumping into cold water can set off the body’s “cold shock response."
WHM safety videosandwritten safety instructionswarn against combining any mysterious breathing utilisation and body of water — but Hof’ssocial media videosoften show him on the face of it doing just that . For example , a2021 YouTube videoshows Hof taking repetitive mysterious hint and then plunging his promontory underwater to have his breathing space .
" I did that every day since 44 years ago up till now , " Hof enounce in the video . After make out out of the body of water , he adds , " Back then , I was alone . decently now , millions are doing it ! " The video , which had more than half a million views as of April 3 , then cuts to a collage of masses going into cold water system to follow Hof ’s Pb .
relate : Why do we shiver when we ’re stale ?
Dangers of breath-holding in water
Experts told Live Science that , if people do as Hof does in that 2021 video , they can face life - threatening consequences .
Hyperventilation can cause hoi polloi to black out underwater . Before the WHM gained popularity , decades ' worth of reportsdescribed people drowning after hyperventilate and then holding their breath underwater , something free diver sometimes do because they do n’t use respiration setup .
Hyperventilation and breather holding lessening the carbon dioxide in the blood and the pressure level the gas would usually exert in rip vessels . This delays the wit ’s sign to resurface and breathe , according to a 2015Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reputation . That ’s because , unremarkably , the signal to breathe is triggered when C dioxide levels go up in the blood .
" If you remove it , it ’s like you are gambling with your life,“Dr . Frank Pernett , a pulmonary medicine doctor and doctoral candidate at Mid Sweden University , tell apart Live Science .
Hyperventilation alone can make people slip by out , as can following hyperventilation with a deep breathing space , Pernett said . you may alsoblack out from just doing a breath wait . In all these scenarios , the loss of blood - borne atomic number 6 dioxide causes line vessels to narrow andprevents enough line from reaching the psyche , hasten unconsciousness .
That ’s why merge any flesh of deep ventilation exercise or extend breather grip with water is a bad mind . Pernett , a free loon himself , said three of his booster , all trained diving instructors , have go while training alone in pools . " If you are subaqueous and you swoon , and nobody is there to help , you will die out , " he said .
link : How does a person freeze out to death ?
This is true in H2O of any temperature , but cold water lend unequaled risks because it can trigger the cold stupor response , a reflex that causes you to puff , the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration ( NOAA ) monish .
That answer piddle jumping into cold piddle — as Hofandhis followersdo in some videos — in particular dangerous because a exclusive gasp underwater can be enough to do someone to swim , saidMike Tipton , a prof of human and apply physiology at the University of Portsmouth in the U.K. ( Tipton has written a guide onminimizing the risks of cold - water therapiesand send word frigid - piddle swimming groups . )
Tipton also explain that , when your face move underwater , your organic structure tries to slow up your heart charge per unit , but the dusty jounce reception accelerates it . Activating both responses simultaneously mixes the signal institutionalize to the heart in what ’s calledautonomic conflict , potentially direct toarrhythmias , or maverick heartbeats . NOAA notice these arrhythmias , as well as spike in affection charge per unit and blood pressure tied to the dusty shock reception , can pose a risk of substance nonstarter and virgule in citizenry vulnerable to the conditions .
" What Wim Hof did is about the most grievous thing you may do when you go into cold water , " Tipton told Live Science , in reference to the 2021 video .
Do as I say, not as I do
Multiple people who have reportedly done the WHM external respiration practice in weewee have died .
In 2016 , Amsterdam - free-base newspaperHet Parool reportedthat at least three people had decease after practicing the WHM — specifically while combining the breathing techniques with water absorption . JournalistScott Carneytold Live Science that he’slinked 31 deathsto the method acting , drawing frompublic news reportsand people whoprivately told himabout deaths related to the WHM . Most were drownings , but none have yet been confirmed to have involved the WHM in a Margaret Court of law , Carney notice .
However , WHM representative say they make clear their two practices should n’t be combined .
" Since we heard about people potentially drowning because of malpractice of the WHM breathing in water in 2015 , we warn hoi polloi on how to do the WHM external respiration exercises correctly and how not to apply the WHM breathing exercises,“Isabelle Hof , a spokesperson for the WHM and Wim Hof ’s girl , secern Live Science .
Related : Free divers ' heart rates can devolve as low as 11 round per second
Of the 2021 TV , she say Live Science that the video is n’t part of the " standard WHM curriculum " and not an instructional guide . WHM prophylactic television and its web site tell mass to ride or rest down in a safe space during the breathing physical exertion and to never practice it or any form of deep breathing ahead of or during immersion in or over water .
Isabelle Hof send out Live Science the protocol for " level 1 " certified WHM teacher , and these admit many of the safety tips raised by Tipton and also warn of autonomic dispute . However , this more - detail info is given to aspiring WHM teacher who pay for a line and is not freely available on the company ’s website .
The WHM website’sfrequently asked questionspage propose mass to refer a medical professional before attempting the method — something Tipton also recommended for multitude plan to enter cold water . But under the question " How do you fix yourself before going into the coldness ? " the internet site simply links to avideo of Hoftelling viewers to trust their gut , flavor and hunch .
— Can humans sense wetness ?
— Everybody freezing ! The scientific discipline of the glacial bear club
— These deep - sea weirdos hold their breath for minutes at a time
at long last , the degree of danger flummox by the WHM depends on whether the method acting encompasses what Hof and his followers do in pop Wim Hof - branded video or just what is write on the WHM website .
" If you think that the Wim Hof Method is just the written instructions on his website , then there may not be a major trouble because it includes warnings , " Carney told Live Science . But if everything Wim Hof does is get as an example of his method acting , " then there ’s a huge problem with the Wim Hof Method because he ’s perpetually demonstrating practices which are dangerous . "
This article is for informational purposes only and is not intend to proffer medical advice .
